IDB Lab / Sin Fronteras

    Evaluating Entrepreneurship Training for Migrant Communities in Ecuador

    Ecuador
    164 started
    111 completed
    2024

    Fortell Impact conducted voice-based impact interviews with participants of the Sin Fronteras entrepreneurship programme in Ecuador, capturing how business training translates into real outcomes for migrant and host community entrepreneurs.

    Overview

    Sin Fronteras is an entrepreneurship training programme supporting migrant and host community entrepreneurs in Ecuador. In partnership with IDB Lab, Fortell Impact deployed AI-powered voice interviews to understand how the programme influenced participants' business skills, growth strategies, and economic resilience.

    The study reached 111 participants through a 16-question voice-based survey delivered via WhatsApp, achieving a 68% completion rate. The respondent group was predominantly female, reflecting the programme's reach.

    Measuring the real impact of entrepreneurship training

    Entrepreneurship programmes often struggle to capture their true impact beyond simple output metrics like attendance or graduation rates. Understanding whether training translates into changed business practices, improved skills, and sustainable growth requires hearing directly from participants about what they learned, what they applied, and what barriers remain.

    Capturing entrepreneurship outcomes through voice

    The voice-based approach captured qualitative depth at scale — enabling automated thematic analysis across all responses while preserving individual participant perspectives. This made it possible to identify patterns in how training translates into business outcomes across a diverse group of entrepreneurs.

    Key findings

    The pilot surfaced several vulnerability dynamics that are often underrepresented in income-only assessments.

    Business skills as the primary impact

    The greatest impact of Sin Fronteras was in improving core business skills. Participants consistently highlighted improvements in financial management, marketing strategy, and business planning as the most valuable outcomes of the programme.

    Financial management and marketing valued most

    The vast majority of participants identified training in financial management and marketing as the most useful skills acquired. Participants described learning to manage business finances more effectively and understanding how to reach new market segments.

    Business model refinement over pivot

    Most entrepreneurs expanded their reach and product lines rather than changing their business model entirely, suggesting that the programme effectively strengthened existing ventures rather than encouraging risky pivots. Only a small proportion mentioned fundamentally changing their business approach.

    Job creation and capital access

    A proportion of participants reported hiring new team members after completing the programme. However, access to credit remained a significant challenge, with many entrepreneurs identifying capital as the primary barrier to further growth — particularly for migrants who face documentation requirements for formal lending.

    What this demonstrates for entrepreneurship programmes

    This evaluation illustrates how voice-based AI can capture the nuanced outcomes of entrepreneurship training that standard reporting metrics miss:

    • Training impact is strongest in practical business skills rather than business model innovation
    • Participants apply financial management and marketing skills directly to existing ventures
    • Capital access remains the primary barrier to growth, particularly for migrant entrepreneurs
    • Voice-based evaluation captures the qualitative depth needed to understand how training translates into practice
    • Automated thematic analysis enables rapid synthesis across diverse entrepreneurship contexts

    "Participants described learning to manage business finances more effectively and understanding how to reach new market segments as the most transformative outcomes of the programme."

    On the impact of business skills training

    Decision Impact

    Findings informed programme design improvements and future training curriculum development.

    Have a similar challenge?

    We'd be happy to discuss how we might approach your specific context and requirements.